Ask HN: What currently is the best, nerd-friendly, rootable Android phone?

83 points by azalemeth - 268 Days, 22 Hours ago Hacker News

My network provider has turned off 3G and despite my current device supporting VoLTE appears to have blacklisted it on the basis of its model name and I cannot make calls any more.

I like running rooted Android because of systemwide adblocking, the ability to run things like Frida and inspect or modify applications, and _ideally_ be something where I can get CTS_BASIC_INTEGRETY – my main bank (Monzo) works with other OSes and rooted phones quite happily, but having the ability to play the highly irritating fun and games is a bonus point. I despise remote attestation and DRM and ideally would have something that fails from the start (!). I'm aware of the security issues with running a rooted Android device; I just frankly don't think that in my threat model that they are that severe. I'd much rather have the freedom to toggle on/off Secure DoH, change my SIP routing, and spoof settings such as my geolocation for legitimately good purposes (e.g. network-level VPN to a different country!).

I've experienced /e/ OS and CyanogenMod in the past and would like a privacy-focussed, ideally open source OS – linux would be perfect but unfortunately it just appears that the totally free Phone OSes aren't ready for prime-time just yet.

What is the best – or perhaps "least worst" – hardware to run something natively rooted on, or an OS like LineageOS? Is there a single manufacturer that supports this? At the moment I probably lean towards the Fairphone 5 but I honestly would love to know of the least worst option.